| 2025 |
| Quarterfinal |
No. 4 Gustavus |
3 |
No. 5 Bethel |
0 |
|
| Quarterfinal |
No. 6 Saint John's |
2 |
No. 3 Augsburg |
1 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 1 St. Olaf |
3 |
No. 6 Saint John's |
1 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 2 Macalester |
2 |
No. 4 Gustavus |
1 |
|
| Championship |
No. 2 Macalester |
4 |
No. 1 St. Olaf |
1 |
|
| Macalester earned the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament while St. Olaf, Augsburg, and Gustavus received at-large berths. |
| 2024 |
| Quarterfinal |
No. 5 Carleton |
5 |
No. 4 Bethel |
2 |
|
| Quarterfinal |
No. 3 Augsburg (2OT) |
1 |
No. 6 Macalester |
0 |
2OT |
| Semifinal |
No. 1 Gustavus |
3 |
No. 5 Carleton |
2 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 2 St. Olaf |
4 |
No. 3 Augsburg |
1 |
|
| Championship |
No. 2 St. Olaf |
3 |
No. 1 Gustavus |
2 |
|
| St. Olaf earned the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament while Gustavus received an at-large bid. St. Olaf defeated Wartburg, 3-1, in the first round before falling on penalty kicks to UW-Superior (4-2) after a 2-2 draw in round two. Gustavus topped MSOE, 3-1, in the first round but lost to UW-Platteville, 1-0, in the second round. |
| 2023 |
| Quarterfinal |
No. 3 Gustavus |
2 |
No. 6 Saint John's |
0 |
|
| Quarterfinal |
No. 4 Macalester |
2 |
No. 5 Augsburg |
0 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 1 St. Olaf |
2 |
No. 4 Macalester |
1 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 3 Gustavus |
1 |
No. 2 Carleton |
0 |
|
| Championship |
No. 1 St. Olaf |
1 |
No. 3 Gustavus |
1 |
PK |
| St. Olaf earned the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament while Carleton and Gustavus received at-large berths. St. Olaf went on to win the NCAA Division III national championship. The Oles defeated UW-Superior in the first round, 7-1, and Carleton in the second round, 1-0, before topping UW-Eau Claire, 4-3, in the Sweet 16 and Chicago, 2-1, in the Elite 8. St. Olaf defeated Washington (Md.), 3-1, in the Final Four before winning 2-1 against Amherst in the national championship. Carleton advanced on penalty kicks against Pacific Lutheran in the opening round before falling to St. Olaf in the round of 32. Gustavus lost to Calvin, 4-1, in first-round play. |
| 2022 |
| Quarterfinal |
No. 6 Saint John's |
1 |
No. 3 Macalester |
0 |
|
| Quarterfinal |
No. 5 Bethel |
1 |
No. 4 Carleton |
0 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 1 Gustavus |
1 |
No. 6 Saint John's |
0 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 2 St. Olaf |
3 |
No. 5 Bethel |
0 |
|
| Championship |
No. 2 St. Olaf |
2 |
No. 1 Gustavus |
1 |
|
| St. Olaf received the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament, while Gustavus earned an at-large berth. St. Olaf defeated Aurora (2-0), UW-Eau Claire (1-1, SO), and St. Olaf (2-2, SO) before falling to Chicago (1-0) in the Elite 8. St. Olaf moved past Lake Forest (8-1) and North Central (2-1) before falling on penalty kicks in the Sweet 16 against Gustavus. |
| 2021 |
| Quarterfinal |
No. 6 Saint John's |
2 |
No. 3 Gustavus |
1 |
OT |
| Quarterfinal |
No. 5 Macalester |
3 |
No. 4 Augsburg |
2 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 1 St. Olaf |
2 |
No. 6 Saint John's |
1 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 2 Carleton |
1 |
No. 5 Macalester |
0 |
|
| Championship |
No. 2 Carleton |
2 |
No. 1 St. Olaf |
1 |
|
| Carleton received the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament, while St. Olaf earned an at-large berth. Carleton fell to North Park, 4-2, in the first round. The Oles defeated Dominican, 3-0, and Loras, 4-0, before dropping a 1-0 decision to North Park in the Sweet 16. |
| 2020 |
| No championships held due to the COVID-19 pandemic. |
| 2019 |
| Quarterfinal |
No. 3 Carleton |
2 |
No. 6 St. Olaf |
1 |
|
| Quarterfinal |
No. 4 Saint John's |
0 |
No. 5 Macalester |
0 |
PK |
| Semifinal |
No. 1 Gustavus |
6 |
No. 4 Saint John's |
2 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 2 St. Thomas |
3 |
No. 3 Carleton |
0 |
|
| Championship |
No. 1 Gustavus |
3 |
No. 2 St. Thomas |
1 |
|
| Gustavus received the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament and went on to defeat Colorado College, 3-2, in the first round before falling on penalty kicks against North Park in the second round. |
| 2018 |
| Quarterfinal |
No. 3 Macalester |
3 |
No. 6 Hamline |
1 |
|
| Quarterfinal |
No. 5 Augsburg |
0 |
No. 4 St. Thomas |
0 |
PK |
| Semifinal |
No. 5 Augsburg |
1 |
No. 1 Gustavus |
0 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 2 Carleton |
1 |
No. 3 Macalester |
0 |
|
| Championship |
No. 2 Carleton |
1 |
No. 5 Augsburg |
1 |
PK |
| Carleton received the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament, where St. Thomas, Gustavus, and Augsburg joined as at-large berths. Carleton made it past the first round, beating Transylvania 1-0 before falling 2-1 to the University of Chicago in the second round. Gustavus and Augsburg both lost close first-round matches while St. Thomas made it to the third round, where they fell to Luther 1-0. |
| 2017 |
| Quarterfinal |
No. 3 Macalester |
1 |
No. 6 Carleton |
0 |
|
| Quarterfinal |
No. 4 Hamline |
2 |
No. 5 Saint John's |
1 |
OT |
| Semifinal |
No. 1 St. Thomas |
3 |
No. 4 Hamline |
0 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 3 Macalester |
1 |
No. 2 Gustavus |
0 |
|
| Championship |
No. 1 St. Thomas |
5 |
No. 3 Macalester |
2 |
|
| St. Thomas received the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament, where they went on to defeat UW Superior 4-3 and Loras 1-0 in the first and second rounds. The Tommies fell 1-0 in the third round to North Park. |
| 2016 |
| Quarterfinal |
No. 5 Saint John's |
3 |
No. 4 Carleton |
0 |
|
| Quarterfinal |
No. 6 Augsburg |
2 |
No. 3 Gustavus |
1 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 1 St. Thomas |
1 |
No. 6 Augsburg |
0 |
OT |
| Semifinal |
No. 2 Macalester |
2 |
No. 5 Saint John's |
0 |
|
| Championship |
No. 1 St. Thomas |
1 |
No. 2 Macalester |
0 |
|
| St. Thomas received the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament, advancing all the way to the semifinals. The Tommies faced St. Scholastica in the first round, where they won 2-1, followed by a win against Luther, 2-0. Their run continued with a 2-1 win against Benedictine, advancing them to the quarterfinals. There, the Tommies secured their spot in the Final Four with a 3-2 win against Redlands. Their journey ended in the semifinal match, where they fell 2-1 to Tufts. |
| 2015 |
| Quarterfinal |
No. 4 St. Olaf |
1 |
No. 5 Hamline |
0 |
|
| Quarterfinal |
No. 6 St. Thomas |
1 |
No. 3 Carleton |
0 |
OT |
| Semifinal |
No. 4 St. Olaf |
1 |
No. 2 Saint John's |
0 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 6 St. Thomas |
2 |
No. 1 Macalester |
1 |
|
| Championship |
No. 4 St. Olaf |
2 |
No. 6 St. Thomas |
0 |
|
| St. Olaf received the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament, while Macalester earned an at-large berth. Macalester and St. Olaf faced each other in the second round after beating St. Scholastica, 1-0, and Oshkosh, 2-0, respectively. St. Olaf came out on top in the match-up, as Macalester fell 1-0. The Oles' run ended in the Sweet 16 with a 2-1 loss to Wheaton. |
| 2014 |
| Quarterfinal |
No. 3 Carleton |
2 |
No. 6 St. Thomas |
0 |
|
| Quarterfinal |
No. 4 Saint John's |
2 |
No. 5 Macalester |
0 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 4 Saint John's |
4 |
No. 1 St. Olaf |
0 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 2 Gustavus |
1 |
No. 3 Carleton |
0 |
|
| Championship |
No. 2 Gustavus |
2 |
No. 4 Saint John's |
0 |
|
| Gustavus received the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament, where they advanced past Dominican 1-0 in the first round. The Gusties fell to Loras 2-0 in the second round. |
| 2013 |
| Semifinal |
No. 4 Saint John's |
2 |
No. 1 Gustavus |
0 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 3 Carleton |
1 |
No. 2 St. Olaf |
0 |
|
| Championship |
No. 3 Carleton |
2 |
No. 4 Saint John's |
1 |
|
| Carleton received the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament, where Gustavus joined them as an at-large berth. Carleton lost to Westminster 1-0 in the first round. Gustavus beat St. Scholastica 2-1 to advance to the second round, where they faced the same fate as the Knights, falling to Westminster 1-0. |
| 2012 |
| Semifinal |
No. 1 Carleton |
2 |
No. 4 Saint John's |
0 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 2 Gustavus |
1 |
No. 3 St. Thomas |
0 |
|
| Championship |
No. 2 Gustavus |
0 |
No. 1 Carleton |
0 |
PK |
| Gustavus received the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament, and Carleton earned a spot with an at-large berth. Both teams fell in the first round, Carleton losing, 1-0, to Carroll, and Gustavus ending their season in a close loss to UW Platteville, going all the way to penalty kicks. |
| 2011 |
| Semifinal |
No. 1 St. Olaf |
2 |
No. 4 Augsburg |
1 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 2 Carleton |
1 |
No. 3 Gustavus |
0 |
|
| Championship |
No. 1 St. Olaf |
3 |
No. 2 Carleton |
2 |
2OT |
| St. Olaf received the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament, where they advanced to the second round, defeating Carroll 3-1. The Oles fell to Luther 1-0, ending their run in the NCAA playoffs. |
| 2010 |
| Semifinal |
No. 2 Augsburg |
1 |
No. 3 Carleton |
0 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 4 Concordia |
3 |
No. 1 Macalester |
1 |
|
| Championship |
No. 2 Augsburg |
3 |
No. 4 Concordia |
2 |
OT |
| Augsburg received the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament while Macalester received an at-large berth. The Scots fell in the first round 2-0 to UW-Whitewater. Augsburg defeated St. Scholastica, 1-0, in the first round, before facing the same fate as Macalester, their season ending with a 3-0 loss to Whitewater in the second round. |
| 2009 |
| Semifinal |
No. 1 Carleton |
3 |
No. 4 St. Thomas |
0 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 2 Macalester |
1 |
No. 3 St. Olaf |
0 |
2OT |
| Championship |
No. 2 Macalester |
1 |
No. 1 Carleton |
0 |
|
| Macalester received the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament, and St. Olaf joined them with an at-large spot. St. Olaf lost 1-0 in the first round to UW-Whitewater. Macalester advanced over Grinnell 2-0 and faced Loras in the second round, where they lost, 2-0. |
| 2008 |
| Semifinal |
No. 1 Carleton |
2 |
No. 4 St. Thomas |
0 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 3 Augsburg |
3 |
No. 2 Gustavus |
0 |
|
| Championship |
No. 1 Carleton |
0 |
No. 3 Augsburg |
0 |
PK |
| Augsburg received the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament while Carleton earned an at-large bid. Augsburg beat Whitworth in penalty kicks, followed by Redlands, 1-0, to advance to the NCAA sectionals, where they lost to Loras 2-1. Carleton followed suit in making it to sectional play with a first-round bye and second-round win against UW-Platteville. The Knights fell to Middlebury, 1-0, in the sectional match. |
| 2007 |
| Semifinal |
No. 4 St. Olaf |
1 |
No. 1 Carleton |
0 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 2 Gustavus |
2 |
No. 3 St. Thomas |
1 |
|
| Championship |
No. 2 Gustavus |
2 |
No. 4 St. Olaf |
0 |
|
| Gustavus earned the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament, where they lost to Whitworth in overtime 2-1 in the first round. |
| 2006 |
| Semifinal |
No. 4 Hamline |
1 |
No. 1 Saint John's |
0 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 2 Gustavus |
1 |
No. 3 Augsburg |
0 |
|
| Championship |
No. 2 Gustavus |
2 |
No. 4 Hamline |
0 |
|
| Gustavus received the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament. The Gusties beat Loras 1-0, advancing to the second round before falling to Wartburg 1-0. |
| 2005 |
| Semifinal |
No. 1 Macalester |
1 |
No. 4 Hamline |
0 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 3 Saint John's |
0 |
No. 2 Gustavus |
0 |
2OT |
| Championship |
No. 3 Saint John's |
1 |
No. 1 Macalester |
0 |
OT |
| Saint John's received the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament, where Macalester and Gustavus joined them as at-large bids. Macalester beat North Park (1-0) before falling to Loras (2-0) in the second round. Saint John's lost in the first round to the University of Chicago (3-2) in double overtime. Gustavus beat Hope (1-0) and Wheaton (3-1) on penalty kicks to advance to the playoff sectionals. The Gusties continued their run, beating Loras (3-0), Fredonia State (2-0), and Whitworth (2-1) to advance to the NCAA Championship match, where they fell to Messiah, 1-0. |
| 2004 |
| Semifinal |
No. 1 Gustavus |
1 |
No. 4 Bethel |
0 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 3 Macalester |
2 |
No. 2 St. Olaf |
0 |
|
| Championship |
No. 1 Gustavus |
3 |
No. 3 Macalester |
0 |
|
| Gustavus earned the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament, where they received a first-round bye and advanced to the third round, beating UW-Whitewater 5-4 in penalty kicks. The Gusties won against Trinity 1-0 to make it to the Elite Eight, where they fell to UC Santa Cruz 1-0. |
| 2003 |
| Semifinal |
No. 1 Macalester |
2 |
No. 4 St. Thomas |
0 |
|
| Semifinal |
No. 2 Gustavus |
3 |
No. 3 Saint John's |
0 |
|
| Championship |
No. 2 Gustavus |
2 |
No. 1 Macalester |
1 |
|
| Gustavus earned the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament and advanced to the second round over Wartburg 2-0 on penalty kicks. The Gusties lost to Redlands on penalty kicks, falling short, 4-3. |