MIAC Men's Soccer Playoff History

 All-Time Men's Soccer Playoff Standings    
 School Win Loss Pct. Games Championships Appearances
 Gustavus 18 11 .621 29 7 (2003-04-06-07-12-14-19) 18 (2003-04-05-06-07-09-11-12-13-14-16-17-18-19-21-22-23-24)
 St. Olaf 13 7 .650 20 5 (2011-15-22-23-24) 12 (2004-07-09-11-13-14-15-19-21-22-23-24)
 Carleton 14 13 .519 27 4 (2008-13-18-21) 17 (2007-08-09-10-11-12-13-14-15-16-17-18-19-21-22-23-24)
 St. Thomas 7 9 .438 16 2 (2016-17) 11 (2003-07-08-09-12-14-15-16-17-18-19)
 Macalester 11 14 .458 24 1 (2009) 15 (2003-04-05-09-10-14-15-16-17-18-19-21-22-23-24)
 Saint John's 9 12 .429 21 1 (2005) 13 (2003-05-06-12-13-14-15-16-17-19-21-22-23)
 Augsburg 7 8 .467 15 1 (2010) 9 (2006-08-10-11-16-18-21-23-24)
 Hamline 2 5 .286 7 -- 5 (2005-06-15-17-18)
 Concordia 1 1 .500 2 -- 1 (2010)
 Bethel 1 3 .250 4 -- 3 (2004-22-24)

 2024
 Quarterfinal No. 5 Carleton 5 No. 4 Bethel 2
 Quarterfinal No. 3 Augsburg (2OT) 1 No. 6 Macalester 0
 Semifinal No. 1 Gustavus 3 No. 5 Carleton 2
 Semifinal No. 2 St. Olaf 4 No. 3 Augsburg 1
 Championship No. 2 St. Olaf 3 No. 1 Gustavus 2
St. Olaf earned the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament while Gustavus received an at-large bid. St. Olaf defeated Wartburg, 3-1, in the first round before falling on penalty kicks to UW-Superior (4-2) after a 2-2 draw in round two. Gustavus topped MSOE, 3-1, in the first round but lost to UW-Platteville, 1-0, in the second round.
 2023
 Quarterfinal No. 3 Gustavus 2 No. 6 Saint John's 0
 Quarterfinal No. 4 Macalester 2 No. 5 Augsburg 0
 Semifinal No. 1 St. Olaf 2 No. 4 Macalester 1
 Semifinal No. 3 Gustavus 1 No. 2 Carleton 0
 Championship No. 1 St. Olaf 1 No. 3 Gustavus 1
St. Olaf earned the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament while Carleton and Gustavus received at-large berths. St. Olaf went on to win the NCAA Division III national championship. The Oles defeated UW-Superior in the first round, 7-1, and Carleton in the second round, 1-0, before topping UW-Eau Claire, 4-3, in the Sweet 16 and Chicago, 2-1, in the Elite 8. St. Olaf defeated Washington (Md.), 3-1, in the Final Four before winning 2-1 against Amherst in the national championship. Carleton advanced on penalty kicks against Pacific Lutheran in the opening round before falling to St. Olaf in the round of 32. Gustavus lost to Calvin, 4-1, in first-round play.
 2022
 Quarterfinal No. 6 Saint John's 1 No. 3 Macalester 0
 Quarterfinal No. 5 Bethel 1 No. 4 Carleton 0
 Semifinal No. 1 Gustavus 1 No. 6 Saint John's 0
 Semifinal No. 2 St. Olaf 3 No. 5 Bethel 0
 Championship No. 2 St. Olaf 2 No. 1 Gustavus 1
St. Olaf received the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament, while Gustavus earned an at-large berth. St. Olaf defeated Aurora (2-0), UW-Eau Claire (1-1, SO), and St. Olaf (2-2, SO) before falling to Chicago (1-0) in the Elite 8. St. Olaf moved past Lake Forest (8-1) and North Central (2-1) before falling on penalty kicks in the Sweet 16 against Gustavus.
 2021    
 Quarterfinal No. 6 Saint John's 2 No. 3 Gustavus 1
 Quarterfinal No. 5 Macalester 3 No. 4 Augsburg 2
 Semifinal No. 1 St. Olaf 2 No. 6 Saint John's 1
 Semifinal No. 2 Carleton 1 No. 5 Macalester 0
 Championship No. 2 Carleton 2 No. 1 St. Olaf 1
Carleton received the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament, while St. Olaf earned an at-large berth. Carleton fell to North Park, 4-2, in the first round. The Oles defeated Dominican, 3-0, and Loras, 4-0, before dropping a 1-0 decision to North Park in the Sweet 16.
 2020    
No championships held due to COVID-19 pandemic.
 2019
 Quarterfinal No. 3 Carleton 2 No. 6 St. Olaf 1
 Quarterfinal No. 4 Saint John's 0 No. 5 Macalester 0
 Semifinal No. 1 Gustavus 6 No. 4 Saint John's 2
 Semifinal No. 2 St. Thomas 3 No. 3 Carleton 0
 Championship No. 1 Gustavus 3 No. 2 St. Thomas 1
Gustavus received the MIAC's automatic qualifier to the NCAA Tournament and went on to defeat Colorado College, 3-2, in the first round before falling on penalty kicks against North Park in the second round.
 2018    
 Quarterfinal No. 3 Macalester 3 No. 6 Hamline 1
 Quarterfinal No. 5 Augsburg 0 No. 4 St. Thomas 0
 Semifinal No. 5 Augsburg 1 No. 1 Gustavus 0
 Semifinal No. 2 Carleton 1 No. 3 Macalester 0
 Championship No. 2 Carleton 1 No. 5 Augsburg 1
 2017    
 Quarterfinal No. 3 Macalester 1 No. 6 Carleton 0
 Quarterfinal No. 4 Hamline 2 No. 5 Saint John's 1
 Semifinal No. 1 St. Thomas 3 No. 4 Hamline 0
 Semifinal No. 3 Macalester 1 No. 2 Gustavus 0
 Championship No. 1 St. Thomas 5 No. 3 Macalester 2
 2016    
 Quarterfinal No. 5 Saint John's 3 No. 4 Carleton 0
 Quarterfinal No. 6 Augsburg 2 No. 3 Gustavus 1
 Semifinal No. 1 St. Thomas 1 No. 6 Augsburg 0
 Semifinal No. 2 Macalester 2 No. 5 Saint John's 0
 Championship No. 1 St. Thomas 1 No. 2 Macalester 0
 2015    
 Quarterfinal No. 4 St. Olaf 1 No. 5 Hamline 0
 Quarterfinal No. 6 St. Thomas 1 No. 3 Carleton 0
 Semifinal No. 4 St. Olaf 1 No. 2 Saint John's 0
 Semifinal No. 6 St. Thomas 2 No. 1 Macalester 1
 Championship No. 4 St. Olaf 2 No. 6 St. Thomas 0
 2014    
 Quarterfinal No. 3 Carleton 2 No. 6 St. Thomas 0
 Quarterfinal No. 4 Saint John's 2 No. 5 Macalester 0
 Semifinal No. 4 Saint John's 4 No. 1 St. Olaf 0
 Semifinal No. 2 Gustavus 1 No. 3 Carleton 0
 Championship No. 2 Gustavus 2 No. 4 Saint John's 0
 2013    
 Semifinal No. 4 Saint John's 2 No. 1 Gustavus 0
 Semifinal No. 3 Carleton 1 No. 2 St. Olaf 0
 Championship No. 3 Carleton 2 No. 4 Saint John's 1
 2012
 Semifinal No. 1 Carleton 2 No. 4 Saint John's 0
 Semifinal No. 2 Gustavus 1 No. 3 St. Thomas 0
 Championship No. 2 Gustavus 0 No. 1 Carleton 0
 2011    
 Semifinal No. 1 St. Olaf 2 No. 4 Augsburg 1
 Semifinal No. 2 Carleton 1 No. 3 Gustavus 0
 Championship No. 1 St. Olaf 3 No. 2 Carleton 2
 2010    
 Semifinal No. 2 Augsburg 1 No. 3 Carleton 0
 Semifinal No. 4 Concordia 3 No. 1 Macalester 1
 Championship No. 2 Augsburg 3 No. 4 Concordia 2
 2009    
 Semifinal No. 1 Carleton 3 No. 4 St. Thomas 0
 Semifinal No. 2 Macalester 1 No. 3 St. Olaf 0
 Championship No. 2 Macalester 1 No. 1 Carleton 0
 2008    
 Semifinal No. 1 Carleton 2 No. 4 St. Thomas 0
 Semifinal No. 3 Augsburg 3 No. 2 Gustavus 0
 Championship No. 1 Carleton 0 No. 3 Augsburg 0
 2007    
 Semifinal No. 4 St. Olaf 1 No. 1 Carleton 0
 Semifinal No. 2 Gustavus 2 No. 3 St. Thomas 1
 Championship No. 2 Gustavus 2 No. 4 St. Olaf 0
 2006    
 Semifinal No. 4 Hamline 1 No. 1 Saint John's 0
 Semifinal No. 2 Gustavus 1 No. 3 Augsburg 0
 Championship No. 2 Gustavus 2 No. 4 Hamline 0
 2005    
 Semifinal No. 1 Macalester 1 No. 4 Hamline 0
 Semifinal No. 3 Saint John's 0 No. 2 Gustavus 0
 Championship No. 3 Saint John's 1 No. 1 Macalester 0
 2004    
 Semifinal No. 1 Gustavus 1 No. 4 Bethel 0
 Semifinal No. 3 Macalester 2 No. 2 St. Olaf 0
 Championship No. 1 Gustavus 3 No. 3 Macalester 0
 2003    
 Semifinal No. 1 Macalester 2 No. 4 St. Thomas 0
 Semifinal No. 2 Gustavus 3 No. 3 Saint John's 0
 Championship No. 2 Gustavus 2 No. 1 Macalester 1